NYX Micro Brow Pencil — Ultra-Fine Retractable Eyebrow Pencil (Ash Brown)

Reviews

1. S Sabrina 3/5

   Color Was Too Light and Tip Broke

   The shade I received was much paler than expected and the pencil snapped easily when I used it. I’d recommend checking color samples first if possible.

2. S Sarah 5/5

   A Staple for Filling Sparse Brows

   This pencil is great for precise filling — it helps me define sparse areas without looking heavy or clownish. It’s become a regular in my makeup kit and I’ll keep buying it.

3. B Beth 5/5

   Precise Application and All-Day Hold

   This pencil offers accurate placement so I can add color exactly where I want it without heavy lines. It stays in place throughout the day with no smudging, and the spoolie end is useful for blending. My only gripe is the mismatch in cap sizes; I’ve accidentally fitted them the wrong way and flattened the tip. Still, it’s a reliable pencil I plan to repurchase.

4. V Vivian V. 5/5

   Smooth, Subtle Coverage That Works With Gray Hair

   The formula applies smoothly and deposits just the right amount of color for a natural look with my gray hair. It’s easy to use and gives a soft finish without looking overdone. Very pleased with this find.

5. M Meg Nicole 5/5

   My Go-To Product for Everyday Brows

   I’ve been using the Taupe shade for years and it remains my top pick. The fine tip allows precise shaping and the finish looks natural all day. I’ve repurchased it multiple times and plan to keep using it.

6. S Sarah 5/5

   Shade 6 Gives a Softer, More Natural Effect

   I’ve tried a darker shade before but prefer the slightly lighter option for a gentler, more natural brow. The fine tip makes it simple to draw tiny, hair-like strokes and the spoolie buffs everything into place. If you want a subtler look than a darker shade provides, try the lighter option.

7. G Gen Bea 5/5

   Builds Color Gradually for a Realistic Finish

   I used to rely on in-person demos but now read reviews before buying. At first the pencil seemed faint and I needed several strokes, which I thought was a drawback. After wearing it a while I appreciated the subtle buildability — it’s much easier to add pigment in layers than to remove too much. I picked Taupe and it suits my very sparse brows perfectly.

8. M Molly 5/5

   Affordable Option That Competes with High-End Picks

   I can make delicate hair strokes easily and the color stays put when I pair it with a brow gel. It also blends out for a fuller effect if desired. This is my second tube and I’ll buy it again.

9. S Surra Puzicha 5/5

   Great Color Match and Long Wear

   The shade matched my hair nicely and the pencil glided on without crumbling or smudging. It kept my brows in shape all day and allowed precise definition of individual hairs. Highly recommend for a natural brow look.

10. D Della 4/5

    Excellent Stand-In for My Former Shade

    I was worried when my usual shade became unavailable, so I searched for a strawberry-blonde-friendly match. This pencil recreated the look I was missing: visible, natural brows that blend with my hair tone without looking painted on. It behaves similarly to my former go-to and finally gave me consistent results.

11. A Alby87 5/5

    Precise Definition with a Natural Finish

    This dual-ended pencil combines a micro tip for accurate application and a spoolie for effortless blending. The formula holds up in warm or humid conditions and gives a neat, natural shape—handy for everyday use and more polished looks.

12. A Amazn Customer 5/5

    Works Well for Dark Hair Without Looking Drawn On

    If you have dark brows and hair, this product helps define without appearing too stark. Use a light hand and feathered strokes to build the look you want.